• Vi gir støtte til energi- og klimatiltak.
Framtiden i våre hender

Expert Group's Report on Coal - A voice from the past

NGOs Slam Expert Group’s Report on Coal and Oil Investments of the Norwegian Government Pension Fund

Press Release 4.12.2014, from Urgewald, Future in our hands/Framtiden i våre hender and Greenpeace Norway

“Given the mandate and the composition of the Expert Group, our expectations were low to begin with,” says Arild Hermstad of the Future in our Hands, “but the Expert Group’s report has managed to underwhelm even these very low expectations. The report does not address or even acknowledge the fact that the Pension Fund’s investments have real and tangible impacts on our climate. And it refutes the idea that large investors have the responsibility to realign their investments with the goal of limiting global warming to 2°C. This is in stark contrast to the latest calls by IPCC, the World Bank and the International Energy Agency.”

The 6 person Expert Group, led by the former Norwegian finance ministry bureaucrat Martin Skancke, yesterday presented its 70 page report “Fossil Fuel Investments in the Norwegian Government Pension Fund Global: Addressing Climate Issues through Exclusion and Active Ownership”. The report was issued just two weeks after Norway’s largest private pension fund KLP had announced its divestment from major coal-based utilities and coal mining companies.

“It is shameful that Norway’s largest private pension funds are far more willing to take responsible action on climate change than Norway’s sovereign wealth fund,” says Truls Gulowsen of Greenpeace Norway. “The recommendations of the Expert Group are simply business as usual. Instead of a meaningful divestment from the most carbon-intensive parts of the fossil fuel industry, the report tells us active ownership is the answer. It completely ignores the fact that Norges Bank’s active ownership activities on climate have up to now shown no discernible results.” The report only advocates an extremely limited case-by-case approach towards exclusion. “This approach is completely unacceptable and would at best lead to the exclusion of only a handful of companies. It is far too little and too late to truly address climate concerns,” says Gulowsen.

Just last week, the Future in our Hands, Greenpeace Norway and the German NGO Urgewald published the report “Dirty & Dangerous” which puts forward concrete criteria for a divestment of the Government Pension Fund from the coal sector. Download the report here.

“It is hard to take the Expert Group’s report serious,” comments Heffa Schücking, director of Urgewald. She criticizes that the Expert Group lumps together the very different issues confronting the transportation and energy sectors, and completely fails to differentiate between coal and oil. “There is no point in setting up an Expert Group if all it does is parrot industry claims about future demand in fossil fuels. Instead of exploring different options for divestment from the most carbon-intensive parts of the industry, the Expert Group simply claims it would be too difficult to conceptualize consistent criteria – something we have just done in our own study. The way we see it, the Expert Group absolutely failed to do its homework,” she adds.

What worries the NGOs most, however, is that the Expert Group, the Norwegian Finance Ministry and Norges Bank all fail to recognize that the Pension Fund’s investments are helping to fuel an ongoing boom of the coal industry and to lock-in energy and mining infrastructure that may undermine all chances of maintaining climate stability. “When buying new shares of Coal India or bonds issued by Sinopec to finance its planned US$ 10 billion coal-to-gas facility, the Government Pension Fund is helping to put us all on the highway to hell,” says Schücking.

“The Pension Fund is currently invested in companies responsible for 42% of world coal production. Coal is easily replaceable and it is time to stop pretending that these destructive investments don’t contradict Norway’s climate obligations or won’t affect the future of Norwegian people,” demands Hermstad.

“Luckily, the final decision is up to the Norwegian Parliament,” says Gulowsen “and the majority here is in favor of divestment from coal. We will do our best to ensure that this majority is not swayed when it comes to a final decision next spring. Our own study shows not only that coal divestment can be done, but that it can be done easily.”

For more information contact:

Heffa Schücking: Denne e-postadressen er beskyttet mot programmer som samler e-postadresser. Du må aktivere javaskript for å kunne se den. or +49 160 96761436

Truls Gulowsen: Denne e-postadressen er beskyttet mot programmer som samler e-postadresser. Du må aktivere javaskript for å kunne se den. or +47 901 07 904

Arild Hermstad: Denne e-postadressen er beskyttet mot programmer som samler e-postadresser. Du må aktivere javaskript for å kunne se den. or +47 980 36 762

Norwegian involvment in Indonesia's coal production

More than 18 billion kroners has been invested in Indonesian coal by the Norwegian Government Pension Fund, according to an investigation by Future in our hands.

Apple of Discord

Mobile phone companies have managed to make small masterpieces of technology and entertainment. But they have not succeeded in avoiding scandal and terrible working conditions. The Future in Our Hands has visited one of the cities where iPhone is produced: Shenzhen in China.

Norway invests in controversial Coal, Oil and Gas

Norway’s two most prominent economic participants – The Government Pension Fund Global and Statoil – are investing billions in 14 big carbon projects that will make it impossible to reduce the climate changes in time. In a new investigation, The Future in Our Hands has identified more than 100 oil fund companies that are investing in increased extraction of coal, oil and gas all over the globe.

Only 1% of Cocoa from Poor Countries

Even though sugar, coffee and cocoa are grown in developing countries, Norway imports these products from Europe. While developing countries produce the raw materials, a large share of the profits remains in Europe.

Norway Invests More in Tax Havens than in Sweden

Norwegian investments in tax havens are increasing. In 2010 Norwegian investors placed more money in exotic tax havens than in Sweden.

The Pension Fund’s Carbon Bubble

The Norwegian Government Pension Fund – Global has shares in 90 of the world’s 100 largest oil companies listed on stock exchanges and in 67 of the 100 largest coal companies. Altogether NKR 241 billion are invested in companies that own more carbon than what we can use if the world is to fulfil the 2ºC goal. This is shown by a calculation made by The Future in Our Hands.

Pension Fund Company accused of Forced Labour

The Canadian mining company Nevsun is accused of profiting from forced labour. The Norwegian Government Pension Fund – Global has invested NKR 74 million in the company.

The Pension Fund Profits from Gold Rush in Eritrea

Eritrea’s youth is fleeing the country by the thousands to get away from forced labour and one of the world’s most repressive countries. The authoritarian government of Eritrea has invited international mining companies to participate in the extraction of gold, copper, and other minerals. The Norwegian Government Pension Fund – Global is taking part in the gold rush, as investor in three mining companies in Eritrea, which all contribute to maintaining the controversial regime.

Bitter Drops in South African Wine

The farm workers’ story of how South Africa’s wine is produced is seldom heard. A bottle of red wine from the wrong vineyard carries the scent of suppression and the taste of bitter tears.

The Church Admits to Violations

The Church of Norway has, through Opplysningsvesenets Fond (OvF), made a show of ethical investments in tree-planting companies in Mozambique. But the reduction in poverty and the afforestation remained on paper only. OvF now admits that agricultural land has been stolen from farmers with small holdings and original forest has been cut down.

About Us

  • We think the sustainability of nature and the climate are more important than growth in consumption and the economy of rich countries.
  • We work to make government and business facilitate green and ethical choices.
  • We are committed to the global environment and a globally fair distribution of wealth. We believe the two are inseparably linked, in a way that requires us to work on both subjects in an integrated way.
- Annonse -